Daniel Flatley, Laura Litvan and Jennifer Jacobs
Washington | President Donald Trump claimed that he’s unfamiliar with the Proud Boys, a right-wing vigilante group he advised to “stand back and stand by” during Tuesday’s debate, and said they should step aside to let police regulate protests.
“I don’t know who the Proud Boys are,” Trump told reporters before departing the White House for a fundraiser and rally in Minnesota on Wednesday (Thursday AEST). “Whoever they are, they need to stand down, let law enforcement do their work.”
Trump has drawn criticism for declining to directly condemn White supremacy at the invitation of the debate moderator, Fox News host Chris Wallace. After Wallace suggested Trump tell groups like the Proud Boys to “stand down”, Trump responded, “Proud Boys, stand back and stand by.”
Members of the group celebrated the remark on social media.
On Wednesday, the White House and some GOP allies backed Trump’s remarks on White supremacy, noting that he said “sure”, “I’m willing to do that” and “I’m willing to do anything” in response to Wallace’s entreaties to condemn the groups.
But the only Black Republican senator called on the President to “correct” his comments.
“I think he misspoke,” Senator Tim Scott of South Carolina told reporters Wednesday at the Capitol. He added, curtly: “I think he should correct it. If he doesn’t correct it I guess he didn’t misspeak.”
Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and Senator Lindsey Graham supported Scott’s statement.
“It was not Lincoln-Douglas,” McConnell told reporters about the debate. “With regard to the White supremacy issue, I want to associate myself with the remarks of Senator Tim Scott that he put out earlier today.”
Scott, McConnell said, “said it was unacceptable not to condemn white supremacists. I do so, in the strongest possible way”.
In a tweet Wednesday, Graham said: “I agree with @SenatorTimScott statement about President Trump needing to make it clear Proud Boys is a racist organisation antithetical to American ideals.”
After his remarks on the Proud Boys at the debate, Trump pivoted to blame the far-left anti-fascist movement known as antifa for violence, even though his nominee for Homeland Security secretary has said White supremacists are the “most persistent and lethal threat” to the US from within the country.
Trump campaign spokesman Hogan Gidley and White House spokeswoman Alyssa Farah both said Wednesday morning that Trump’s response — “sure” — to Wallace’s question amounted to a condemnation.
“He says ‘sure’ right out of the gate to that question,” Farah told Fox News.
“How many times, how many ways does he have to say it?” Gidley said in a Wednesday morning interview on CNN that focused largely on Trump’s views on White supremacy groups.
They also downplayed his remarks that the Proud Boys should “stand back and stand by”, which members of the group interpreted as a call to future action. “I don’t think that there’s anything to clarify. He’s told them to stand back,” Farah said.
Several Republican lawmakers sought to give the President the benefit of the doubt and used the same line of argument as Trump’s aides, saying extremists of all stripes should be condemned.
“He asked, ‘Would you denounce it?’ What’d the president say? ‘Yes. Yes I will’,” House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy said during a news conference. “How many times does he have to say it? If the question is ‘Would you denounce it’ and the answer is ‘Yes,’ he did that.”
McCarthy didn’t answer a follow-up question about Trump’s “stand back and stand by” comment about the “Proud Boys” group but countered by faulting former Vice President Joe Biden for not more forcefully condemning antifa.
“It would be concerning to me that Joe Biden would not believe antifa is a group,” McCarthy said. FBI Director Chris Wray recently testified to the House Homeland Security Committee that antifa is an ideology not an organisation.
Trump on Wednesday tweeted a video of Fox News commentator Dan Bongino, who said the President “brilliantly” played to his core voters during the debate.
“Forget independents, it’s a base election,” Bongino said. “He’s the shark in the ocean and he acted like it. He lost no one from his base. No one.”
Indiana GOP Senator Mike Braun said it’s important to denounce White supremacist groups, and he doesn’t believe Trump intended to stop short of that.”I know for certain that he denounces that,” Braun said. “And I think it’s fair to say you can denounce both sides of radical elements.”
Senator Dick Durbin of Illinois, the No. 2 Democratic leader, said he feels a sense of “outrage” similar to what he felt after the deadly 2017 “Unite the Right” rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, when the President appeared reluctant to condemn right-wing violence and suggested there were “fine people” on both sides.
“The President has to understand White nationalism, White supremacy is unfortunately the leading cause of a lot of domestic terrorism in the United States and he’s just afraid to confront them,” Durbin said. “I’m afraid he believes they’re his followers and he doesn’t want to make them angry before an election.”
Speaking on the Senate floor Wednesday morning, Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said Trump’s remarks in Tuesday’s forum was “one of the most disgraceful performances at a presidential debate that anyone has ever seen”.
“In an hour and a half that felt like a lifetime, the President managed to insult Vice President Biden’s deceased son and smear a living one, please a fringe White supremacist group and capped the night off by yet again casting doubt on our own elections, tarnishing our own democracy,” Schumer said. “Those were just his worst moments.”
Some Republicans suggested that the President should have taken a stronger stance by condemning more forcefully both White supremacists and other radical groups.
“He should have been very clear, and he should have made it very clear that there’s no room for people on the far left or the far more far right,” said Senator Mike Rounds, a Republican from South Dakota. “When it comes to either an antifa or these White supremacist groups, he should have been very clear.”
While not addressing Trump’s comments specifically, Senator Todd Young, an Indiana Republican, said that extremist groups should be condemned.
“I condemn White supremacy, all extremist groups,” Young said. “I think that all of these groups are equal, and I condemn them on the strongest terms, and we need to remain one nation under God.”
The US election Brief is your guide to the 2020 race.
A bonus newsletter for subscribers. Sign up to receive The Brief once a week in your inbox.